Blog post

The Euro Area: Great Recession or Great Depression?

The Great Depression was a period of severe economic contraction that lasted many years. In the United States real GDP fell every year from 1929 to 19

Publishing date
04 February 2013
Authors
André Sapir

The Great Depression was a period of severe economic contraction that lasted many years. In the United States real GDP fell every year from 1929 to 1933, when it reached only 73 percent of its 1929 level. Starting in 1934 the recovery was quite rapid, with GDP reaching its 1929 level in 1936. By contrast the Great Recession has been much milder (see Figure 1a). In the US GDP only contacted from 2007 to 2009, when it fell to only 96 percent of its 2007 level. Recovery was quick, with GDP already surpassing its 2007 level by 2011. In the euro area, unfortunately, the situation has been less favorable. Although the initial contraction was similar to what happened in the US, recovery has been slower. In 2013, euro area GDP will still be below its 2007 level.

Inside the euro area, the situation is particularly alarming in Greece, Ireland, Italy, Portugal and Spain (see Figure 1b). In the last three countries, the term recession rather than depression is appropriate, but recession is severe: GDP will continue to decline in 2013 while will still remaining above 90 percent of the 2007 level. By contrast, in Greece the term recession is not appropriate. The country is clearly in depression: GDP continues to decline sharply and will reach barely 77 percent of its 2007 level in 2013. This is worse than in the US at a similar stage in time during the Great Depression. The situation of Ireland depends on whether one looks at GDP or GNP (for the other countries GDP and GNP are very similar). GDP fell till 2010 but has grown steadily since 2011. On the other hand, Irish GNP has declined severely since 2007 and although it will stabilize in 2013 it will be worse than in the US at a similar point in time during the Great Depression.

So yes, perhaps the financial crisis in the euro area is over but GDP in the crisis countries (and GNP in Ireland) still has some way to go before it returns to its pre-crisis level. This is surely a depressing situation.     

Figure 1a – Real GDP of the Euro area, Japan and US (2007=100) and the US (1929=100)

First

                               

Figure 1b - Real GDP of the GIIPS (2007=100) and the US (1929=100)

second

Data source:  AMECO, European Commission.

Note:  IrelandD (N) stands for Ireland’s GDP (GNP).

About the authors

  • André Sapir

    André Sapir, a Belgian citizen, is a Senior fellow at Bruegel. He is also University Professor at the Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB) and Research fellow of the London-based Centre for Economic Policy Research.

    Between 1990 and 2004, he worked for the European Commission, first as Economic Advisor to the Director-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, and then as Principal Economic Advisor to President Prodi, also heading his Economic Advisory Group. In 2004, he published 'An Agenda for a Growing Europe', a report to the president of the Commission by a group of independent experts that is known as the Sapir report. After leaving the Commission, he first served as External Member of President Barroso’s Economic Advisory Group and then as Member of the General Board (and Chair of the Advisory Scientific Committee) of the European Systemic Risk Board based at the European Central Bank in Frankfurt.

    André has written extensively on European integration, international trade and globalisation. He holds a PhD in economics from the Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, where he worked under the supervision of Béla Balassa. He was elected Member of the Academia Europaea and of the Royal Academy of Belgium for Science and the Arts.

Related content