Blog Post

Social distancing: did individuals act before governments?

Using online searches for restaurants as a proxy to assess whether and to what extent individuals were practicing social distancing before strict lockdown measures, we identify substantial differences between countries. In some countries, including Denmark and Portugal, searches for restaurants were considerably down before restaurant restrictions were put in place. Countries where social distancing started earlier, regardless of when policies were enacted, can expect a flatter coronavirus curve.

By: Date: April 7, 2020 Topic: Macroeconomic policy

Behavioural change is a fundamental determinant of the spread of an epidemic. Toxvaerd (2020) showed how behavioural parameters change predictions in standard epidemiological models. Even when individuals are considered in models to be purely self-interested, they are bound to engage in some degree of social distancing by choice and thus help reduce the growth rate of the number of infections, compared to that predicted by epidemiological models. Toxvaerd (2020) suggests social distancing is greater when the disease is more contagious and health effects more severe.

Individuals act on the basis of their beliefs about how contagious a disease is and about how severe its effects are. Moreover, they are not necessarily self-interested, but might consider how their actions affect others. Differences in information, risk-aversion and self-interest, and expectations about how well prepared the health system is to deal with the inflow of patients, will lead to different choices in terms of the degree of voluntary social distancing. 

We used Google Trends to identify when individuals started engaging meaningfully in social distancing in different European countries. We used searches for the topic ‘restaurant’ because visiting a restaurant reflects a choice to leave the house, as opposed to trips people might be required to make[1].

We compared each day of the week in February and March 2020 with the same day of the week in January. For example, average Mondays in February and March were compared with average Mondays in January, with the average of January Monday searches set to 100. We plotted a seven-day moving average of this index to show trends and reduce weekly seasonality. The use of this moving average means values depicted lag actual reductions in searches. We plotted the same series for 2019, which show that February and March average searches are slightly above January. Peaks around events such as Valentine’s Day and Carnival (in Portugal) are noticeable. 

Figure 1 shows the results for three countries, and notes in each case the start date of strict lockdown measures, and, where relevant, the date of implementation of initial measures that restricted opening hours or numbers of clients. 

Figure 1: Searches for ‘restaurants’ from 8 January to 30 March in Denmark, France, Spain (January average = 100)

Source: Bruegel based on Google Trends.

Figure 1 shows significant differences between the three countries. Denmark was one of the first countries to impose strict limits on social gatherings but even before, individuals started to reduce their social contacts. A downward trend in restaurant-related searches is visible for Denmark starting on mid-February. These factors might have contributed to the controlled growth of cases in Denmark, whose prime minister on 30 March hinted at the possibility of gradually re-opening the country.

This pattern is entirely different from the same variable plotted in 2019, where searches did not decrease in February/March compared to January, and a Valentine’s Day peak was observable.

For France and Spain, the decrease in searches for restaurants before lockdown measures were implemented was smaller. In Spain, there was a sudden 25% drop three days before full closure, most likely partly related to the announcement made on 14 March and to the critical situation in Madrid. 

Figure 2: Searches for ‘restaurants’ from 8 January to 30 March in Italy, Portugal, Germany (January average = 100)

Source: Bruegel based on Google Trends.

Figure 2 shows that in Italy, there was already a decrease in searches for ‘restaurants’ before national lockdown, most likely partly related to the dire situation and restrictions in Lombardy and to the fact the announcement preceded implementation. 

In Portugal, compared to January, a decrease in the number of searches for restaurants was visible from 11 March, eight days before a national lockdown was put in place, and the decrease accelerated as announcements on restrictions were made. A comparison with 2019 is made difficult by Carnival. For Germany, a reduction in searches was observable more days before lockdown but advanced more gradually, potentially because of state-by-state implementation of measures. 

A policy outlier, showed in Figure 3, is Sweden, where no similarly strict measures are in place. There was still a considerable drop in searches, though searches in Sweden remain above the post-lockdown levels registered in other European countries. 

Figure 3: searches for ‘restaurants’ from 8 January to 30 March in Sweden (January average = 100)

Source: Bruegel based on Google Trends.

Considerable differences in observance of lockdowns even before they formally took effect will contribute to different evolutions of the spread of the disease in different countries. When modelling infection curves, it is relevant to consider these voluntary actions, which took place ahead of required distancing. 

Figure 4 shows the average of indexed searches in the day, three days, five days and seven days before introduction of national restaurant closures. Some countries already had partial restrictions in place, as shown in the charts above, which should be kept in mind when making comparisons:

Figure 4: Searches for restaurants vs. January average (100), 7, 5, 3 and 1 days before nationwide restaurant closures

Source: Bruegel based on Google Trends.

In the UK, where strict measures were implemented only on 23 March, the preceding week’s daily searches were on average 30% lower than in January.

The figures show that even in the absence of government action, if individuals are informed about risk, they seem to choose to engage in social distancing (though reduced restaurant visits do not necessarily mean people were not gathering in other settings). As governments made announcements, people started engaging in social distancing, even before implementation. In countries where government action lags, individuals can promote distancing to help curb disease progression (with economic costs), if they are aware of the risks.  

However, without an encompassing government response and appropriate social measures, individuals will be more susceptible to health risks since even if they avoid outside leisure, they are required to leave their homes to work and secure an income.

[1] We focus on ‘restaurant’ as a topic, not as a search term, which means the values should reflect whenever individuals search for any restaurant.

References

Toxvaerd, Flavio (2020) ‘Equilibrium Social Distancing’, Cambridge Working Papers in Economics: 2021, available at https://www.inet.econ.cam.ac.uk/working-paper-pdfs/wp2008.pdf


Republishing and referencing

Bruegel considers itself a public good and takes no institutional standpoint. Anyone is free to republish and/or quote this post without prior consent. Please provide a full reference, clearly stating Bruegel and the relevant author as the source, and include a prominent hyperlink to the original post.

Read about event More on this topic
 

Past Event

Past Event

Fiscal policy and rules after the pandemic

What are the possibilities for shaping the new fiscal policy?

Speakers: Zsolt Darvas, Maria Demertzis, Michel Heijdra and Katja Lautar Topic: Macroeconomic policy Date: November 24, 2021
Read article More by this author
 

Blog Post

Fiscal arithmetic and risk of sovereign insolvency

The record-high debt levels in advanced economies increase the risk of sovereign insolvency. Governments should start fiscal consolidation soon in an environment of low nominal and real interest rates and post-COVID growth.

By: Marek Dabrowski Topic: Global economy and trade, Macroeconomic policy Date: November 18, 2021
Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

Podcast

Podcast

Pandemonium

How did Europe respond to the pandemic?

By: The Sound of Economics Topic: European governance Date: November 17, 2021
Read about event More on this topic
 

Past Event

Past Event

Phasing out COVID-19 emergency support programmes: effects on productivity and financial stability

How can European countries phase out the COVID-19 support measures without having a negative impact on productivity and financial stability?

Speakers: Eric Bartelsman, Maria Demertzis, Peter Grasmann and Laurie Mayers Topic: Macroeconomic policy Date: November 9, 2021
Read article Download PDF
 

Policy Contribution

European governance

COVID-19 financial aid and productivity: has support been well spent?

While support schemes during the pandemic were not targeted at protecting ‘good’ firms, financial support mostly went to those with the capacity to survive and succeed. Labour schemes have been effective in protecting employment.

By: Carlo Altomonte, Maria Demertzis, Lionel Fontagné and Steffen Müller Topic: European governance, Macroeconomic policy Date: November 4, 2021
Read article
 

Blog Post

European governanceInclusive growth

The socioeconomic effects of COVID-19 on women

The pandemic has disproportionately affected women both professionally and at home. Although the gender gap in labour force participation since the onset of the pandemic hasn't worsened, policy still needs to tackle existing gender gaps, which for some EU countries are very substantive.

By: Maria Demertzis and Mia Hoffmann Topic: European governance, Inclusive growth Date: November 3, 2021
Read article More on this topic
 

External Publication

Elimination versus mitigation of SARS-CoV-2 in the presence of effective vaccines

Article published in Lancet Global Heath on strategies to end the COVID-19 pandemic in the presence of effective vaccines.

By: Miquel Oliu-Barton and Guntram B. Wolff Topic: Global economy and trade Date: November 3, 2021
Read article
 

Blog Post

European governance

Is the risk of stagflation real?

Most economic forecasts predict a return, in the medium-term, to pre-pandemic growth and inflation. Nevertheless, the European Central Bank and fiscal authorities need to be vigilant for signs of the contrary.

By: Monika Grzegorczyk, Francesco Papadia and Pauline Weil Topic: European governance, Macroeconomic policy Date: November 2, 2021
Read article More on this topic
 

Blog Post

Strong, balanced, sustainable and inclusive growth? The G20 and the pandemic

The G20 is not doing enough to support strong, balanced, sustainable and inclusive growth in the wake of COVID-19, with the poorest countries left behind by the recovery.

By: Suman Bery and Pauline Weil Topic: Global economy and trade Date: October 29, 2021
Read article Download PDF
 

Parliamentary Testimony

European ParliamentInclusive growth

Understanding the socioeconomic effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on women

Testimony before the European Parliament's Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs (ECON) on the consequences of the pandemic on women.

By: Maria Demertzis and Mia Hoffmann Topic: European Parliament, Inclusive growth, Macroeconomic policy Date: October 27, 2021
Read article More by this author
 

Blog Post

European governance

Pandemic prevention: avoiding another cycle of ‘panic and neglect’

Agreement is needed at international level on mechanisms to ensure better preparedness for the next pandemic.

By: Anne Bucher Topic: European governance, Global economy and trade Date: October 7, 2021
Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

Opinion

Letter: Declining investment may explain why rates are low

Perhaps an analysis of the causes of the declining investment rate would bring us closer to explaining why real interest rates are so low.

By: Marek Dabrowski Topic: Macroeconomic policy Date: October 1, 2021
Load more posts