Blog Post

Crony Capitalism In America?

Nicolas Véron comments Simon Johnson’s widely-read piece in the Atlantic in which he compares the US situation with many emerging countries’ "crony capitalism". While he essentially agrees with Johnson’s assessment, he also brings some qualifications. Simon Johnson is right in his core diagnosis. Regulatory capture has been all too ignored as an enabler of the […]

By: Date: April 11, 2009 Topic: Global economy and trade

Nicolas Véron comments Simon Johnson’s widely-read piece in the Atlantic in which he compares the US situation with many emerging countries’ "crony capitalism". While he essentially agrees with Johnson’s assessment, he also brings some qualifications.

Simon Johnson is right in his core diagnosis. Regulatory capture has been all too ignored as an enabler of the crisis. Shifting the public conversation towards it, as Johnson does, is an important and welcome contribution. However, as he recognizes, "everyone has elites", and a purely anti-oligarchic agenda is unlikely to be of much help in solving the current mess.
Of course, very little of this is new. Machiavelli masterfully captured the oligarchy question’s complexity when writing: "I maintain that those who blame the quarrels of the Senate and the people of Rome condemn that which was the very origin of liberty, and that they were probably more impressed by the cries and noise which these disturbances occasioned in the public places, than by the good effect which they produced; and that they do not consider that in every republic there are two parties, that of the nobles (i grandi) and that of the people; and all the laws that are favorable to liberty result from the opposition of these parties to each other, as may easily be seen from the events that occurred in Rome." (Discourses on Livy, First Book, Chapter 4, translation by Christian Detmold) To expand on Johnson’s story, three remarks are worth mentioning.
1. The U.S. has not one moneyed oligarchy, but several. Specifically during most of the presidency of George W. Bush, the financial community has been far from dominant in national political power structures. It has been noted that during the years in which President Bush pushed a radical policy agenda, and until well after the Katrina turning point in his popularity, financiers had been rather underrepresented in the administration, certainly when compared with the Clinton era. This situation was symbolized by the successive tenures of Paul O’Neill and John Snow, two non-financial business figures, at the head of the U.S. Treasury. This obviously changed in the spring of 2006 when Joshua Bolten replaced Andrew Card as presidential chief of staff, and other Goldman Sachs alumni including Paulson were appointed to a number of key positions. But the dominant oligarchy during most of the Bush years was made of non-financial CEOs and company owners, not Wall Street types.
2. The U.S. financial oligarchy is surprisingly meritocratic. This is attested by the modest social origins of most latter-days Wall Street titans: think of Sandy Weill, Chuck Prince, John Mack, Dick Grasso, Stan O’Neal, or Lloyd Blankfein. This echoes some other crony capitalism contexts – Russia comes to mind – but differs from others, such as many cases in Latin America, and is unusual in a country with as much recent political stability as America.
3. Even as Johnson argues that the US has "the world’s most advanced oligarchy", it is arguably not the most entrenched, even among developed economies. America has so far been more willing to clamp down on its financial oligarchy than many European countries, and by some measures the gap is increasing as we advance through the crisis. In France, large financial firms exert dominant influence on the government’s stance on financial reform. In Germany, both the finance minister and his state secretary for financial affairs have been involved in the governance of now-failed banks, respectively WestLB and IKB. In the UK, the current prime minister spent many years at the Treasury courting the favors of the financial industry. The European Commission has a track record of being generally less captured than individual member states (as analyzed in Adam Posen’s insightful piece) but Charlie McCreevy’s tenure as Commissioner in charge of financial services has lowered its moral ground.
4. Since the November elections, there is continued evidence that the U.S. Congress is at least partly captured by the financial oligarchy, such as the pressure it recently exerted on the Financial Accounting Standards Board to bend accounting standards and allow banks to further hide the bad news. But the jury is still out as regards the executive branch, and so far there are arguments to give the Obama team the benefit of the doubt. Specifically, the primary reason why the U.S. has not treated its banking sector as Sweden successfully did in 1992 is arguably not the Treasury’s capture by the industry, but rather the lack of broad domestic political consensus, an indispensable condition to take a step as radical as nationalizing a significant number of banks. The key role played by bipartisan consensus in the Swedish crisis is well illustrated by Governor Bäckström’s speech at Jackson Hole in 1997.
All this does not modify Johnson’s harsh verdict, it only puts it into perspective. As to the policy prescriptions, I agree with the need to nationalize insolvent banks à la Sweden 1992, but am less sure that reducing the oligarchy’s power should be an aim in itself; in any case it will not be sufficient. This makes me somewhat skeptical of the proposal to practically put a cap on the size of financial service firms. In other words, I fail to be convinced that the U.S. needs to arbitrarily detain its Mikhail Khodorkovskys or break up its Yukoses. What is needed instead is to upgrade the authority and capability of public institutions (mantenere lo stato, as Machiavelli put it) so that they can keep the oligarchs in check. And as our oligarchy has been going global in the past few years, this is not only a U.S. task, but increasingly a supranational one as well.


Republishing and referencing

Bruegel considers itself a public good and takes no institutional standpoint. Anyone is free to republish and/or quote this post without prior consent. Please provide a full reference, clearly stating Bruegel and the relevant author as the source, and include a prominent hyperlink to the original post.

Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

External Publication

L’Union européenne et les États-Unis, un an après

Après une année troublée par Kaboul et AUKUS, qu'avons-nous retenu de l'an I de la présidence Biden ? Maria Demertzis revient sur les évènements marquants de l'année 2021 pour la relation entre les États-Unis et l'Union européenne.

By: Maria Demertzis Topic: Global economy and trade Date: December 8, 2021
Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

Podcast

Podcast

What to watch in 2022: China's economic outlook

Our end of 2021 recap of China’s economic activities.

By: The Sound of Economics Topic: Global economy and trade Date: December 8, 2021
Read article More by this author
 

Blog Post

European governance

The Global Gateway: a real step towards a stronger Europe in the world?

Disappointment at the lack of fresh cash from European Union global connectivity strategy is short-sighted: Europe supports global development more than any other country in the world. Using existing funds more strategically is the right priority for now.

By: Simone Tagliapietra Topic: European governance, Global economy and trade Date: December 7, 2021
Read about event
 

Past Event

Past Event

China’s medium term outlook: Will innovation save China from becoming old before it becomes rich?

What can China do to stop the deceleration of its economy. Is innovation the solution?

Speakers: Jean-Francois Di Meglio, Alicia García-Herrero and Guntram B. Wolff Topic: Digital economy and innovation, Global economy and trade Date: December 1, 2021
Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

Podcast

Podcast

A new consensus for economic resilience

Is there a need for systemic reform of global economic governance?

By: The Sound of Economics Topic: Global economy and trade Date: December 1, 2021
Read article Download PDF More on this topic More by this author
 

External Publication

Chinese economic statecraft: what to expect in the next five years?

Chapter from 'Storms Ahead: the Future Geoeconomic world order' on the expectations from the next five years of Chinese economic policy, published on 27 October 2021.

By: Alicia García-Herrero Topic: Global economy and trade Date: November 26, 2021
Read about event More on this topic
 

Past Event

Past Event

Advancing global value and supply chains to mitigate the challenges arising from the pandemic

Session at the 1st ASIA-EUROPE ECONOMIC AND BUSINESS FORUM: Transitioning to a New Normal: Leveraging Global Value Chains, Multilateralism and the 4IR

Speakers: Carmen Cano, Alicia García-Herrero, Jong Woo Kang, André Sapir, Luca Silipo and Tetsuya Watanabe Topic: Global economy and trade Location: Phnom Penh, Cambodia Date: November 24, 2021
Read article More by this author
 

Blog Post

Fiscal arithmetic and risk of sovereign insolvency

The record-high debt levels in advanced economies increase the risk of sovereign insolvency. Governments should start fiscal consolidation soon in an environment of low nominal and real interest rates and post-COVID growth.

By: Marek Dabrowski Topic: Global economy and trade, Macroeconomic policy Date: November 18, 2021
Read about event
 

Past Event

Past Event

How can we create more sustainable value chains?

There is an urgent need for GVCs to become more resilient and inclusive, and meet the net-zero challenge.

Speakers: Erik Berglöf and Alicia García-Herrero Topic: Global economy and trade, Green economy Location: Bruegel, Rue de la Charité 33, 1210 Brussels Date: November 10, 2021
Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

Podcast

Podcast

Why is China cracking down on big tech?

A look at China’s recent regulatory efforts in the digital space.

By: The Sound of Economics Topic: Global economy and trade Date: November 10, 2021
Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

Blog Post

What to make of the EU-US deal on steel and aluminium?

While deeply disappointing that the surprise deal maintains aluminium and steel tariffs against the EU beyond a modest quota, it alleviates a major irritant in transatlantic relations and contains interesting and innovative features relating to climate policy and to dispute settlement under WTO rules.

By: Uri Dadush Topic: Global economy and trade Date: November 4, 2021
Read article More on this topic More by this author
 

Podcast

Podcast

The state of trade: the EU's trade policy

A conversation with Member of the European Parliament Bernd Lange on the European Union’s trade policy.

By: The Sound of Economics Topic: Global economy and trade Date: November 3, 2021
Load more posts